Event details from: Stefanie Lemke on Lawyers in Europe 'Advocates of Silenced Voices'

Date
5 October 2021
Time
12:00 – 13:00

This presentation examines the situation of lawyers in Azerbaijan and Russia, and focuses on countries that over the past two decades have repeatedly ignored calls from the international community to guarantee the right to a lawyer and an independent judge. In 2013, the UN Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights Defenders warned that space for civil society and defenders in certain regions of the world was visibly shrinking and that they were being silenced in more sophisticated ways, including by abusing the justice system to criminalize and stigmatize their activities.

In Europe, the increasing politicization of judges is illustrated by the incorporation of the Supreme Court by the Polish Law and Justice Party (PiS) and Hungary's metamorphosis from an admirably independent judiciary to a Viktor Orbán dominated judiciary. As a result, lawyers experience difficulties in handling cases that are politically sensitive. Lawyers representing activists and other critics of the regime are given little time to prepare their clients' defenses, and courts do not follow the rules of a fair trial in such cases. Lawyers themselves are the target of their human rights work: they are threatened and attacked, their licenses are revoked and they are convicted of criminal offences.

Against this background, this presentation examines the important relationship between lawyers and judges, which is essential for ensuring a fair trial. Stefanie Lemke offers a contextual study of a number of European countries, where governments have wide-ranging powers and use the judiciary to undermine the work of lawyers. The presentation ends with a critical assessment of current international human rights mechanisms to more effectively counter judicial harassment of lawyers.

Stefanie Lemke Stefanie Lemke is visiting professor at the International Institute for the Sociology of Law (IISL), researcher at the University of Oxford/Paris Nanterre, and scientific expert at the Council of Europe and the European Commission.

Marc de Werd Marc de Werd is a senior judge at the Amsterdam Court of Appeal, professor of Justice at the University of Amsterdam and a member of the CCJE of the Council of Europe.

For more information, please contact Roland Pierik (R.Pierik@uva.nl)